Pin it
Italian orange cake delivers bright, intense citrus flavor in every moist, tender bite. This traditional recipe incorporates whole fresh oranges for unmatched aromatic quality and tops everything with glistening candied orange slices for visual appeal. The combination of olive oil and yogurt creates an incredibly tender crumb that stays moist for days. Equally suitable for morning coffee, afternoon tea, or dinner party finale, this versatile cake brings Mediterranean sunshine to your table without complicated techniques or hard to find ingredients.
I discovered this cake while visiting family in southern Italy where citrus desserts reign supreme. My aunt served it with afternoon espresso, explaining that local bakers compete for the most fragrant version. The first time I made it at home, my kitchen filled with such incredible orange aroma that neighbors knocked on my door asking what I was baking. Now I make it whenever winter citrus appears at farmers markets, sometimes baking multiple loaves to share with friends who request it specifically.
Essential Cake Components
- Water: Forms the base liquid for simmering perfect candied orange slices
- Granulated Sugar: Provides necessary sweetness without overwhelming the natural orange flavor
- Medium Oranges: Contribute both stunning visual garnish and concentrated flavor throughout
- Large Eggs: Create essential structure while contributing richness to the finished cake
- All Purpose Flour: Provides the basic foundation that allows other flavors to shine
- Kosher Salt: Enhances surrounding flavors and balances sweetness perfectly
- Nutmeg: Offers optional warming background note that complements citrus beautifully
- Baking Powder: Ensures proper rise and light texture throughout the cake
- Olive Oil: Contributes moisture while adding subtle complexity to the flavor profile
- Plain Yogurt: Creates tenderness and slight tanginess that highlights orange notes
- Vanilla Extract: Rounds out the flavor profile with floral aromatic notes
Cake Creation Method
- Candied Orange Preparation:
- Begin by combining sugar and water in a medium saucepan over medium heat, stirring occasionally until sugar completely dissolves. Once mixture reaches a gentle boil, carefully arrange thinly sliced orange rounds in a single layer in the simmering syrup. Reduce heat to maintain a gentle simmer for approximately fifteen minutes until orange slices become translucent and tender. Using a slotted spoon, transfer orange slices to a parchment lined baking sheet, arranging them in a single layer to cool slightly. Reserve the fragrant orange syrup for glazing the finished cake later.
- Orange Pulp Processing:
- Thoroughly wash and dry remaining oranges before using a microplane to remove just the colored zest, avoiding the bitter white pith beneath. Once zested, use a sharp paring knife to carefully remove all remaining white pith from the oranges. This step prevents unwanted bitterness in your cake. Roughly chop the peeled orange segments, removing any seeds you encounter. Transfer prepared orange pieces to a food processor and pulse until smooth, creating a consistency similar to applesauce.
- Batter Creation Technique:
- In a large mixing bowl, whisk eggs and sugar vigorously for approximately five minutes until the mixture becomes pale yellow and noticeably thicker. While continuing to whisk, slowly stream olive oil into the egg mixture, incorporating completely before proceeding. In a separate bowl, whisk together flour, salt, optional nutmeg, and baking powder. Gently fold dry ingredients into wet mixture just until combined, avoiding overmixing. Finally, carefully incorporate yogurt, vanilla extract, and your prepared orange pulp, stirring just until everything comes together.
- Assembly Procedure Details:
- Prepare a nine inch springform pan by greasing thoroughly and lining the bottom with parchment paper. Arrange cooled candied orange slices in a decorative pattern across the bottom of the prepared pan. Pour your completed batter over the arranged orange slices, using a spatula to smooth the top evenly. Place in an oven preheated to 350°F and bake for approximately fifty minutes, or until a toothpick inserted into the center comes out with just a few moist crumbs attached.
Pin it
Serving Situation Ideas
Present thin slices alongside espresso for traditional Italian morning experience that transforms ordinary breakfast into something special. For elegant dinner parties, warm individual portions slightly before topping with dollop of mascarpone cream and fresh berries. Create stunning brunch centerpiece by arranging cake on pedestal surrounded by additional fresh citrus fruits and sprigs of fresh mint.
Flavor Modification Options
Transform into chocolate orange version by adding three tablespoons cocoa powder to dry ingredients for sophisticated flavor combination. Create lemon orange hybrid by substituting one orange with one lemon for brighter, more complex citrus profile. Incorporate Mediterranean influence by adding teaspoon of orange blossom water and quarter cup toasted pistachios to batter before baking.
Pin it
My relationship with this orange cake spans nearly two decades, beginning with that first taste in southern Italy and continuing through countless variations in my own kitchen. What continues to surprise me about this recipe is how such straightforward ingredients and techniques consistently produce something that tastes so special. The way the entire orange integrates into the batter creates flavor impossible to achieve with juice or extract alone.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use different types of oranges for this cake?
- Absolutely! While navel oranges are most common, you can experiment with different varieties for unique flavor profiles. Blood oranges create a beautiful ruby-tinged cake with a slightly berry-like flavor. Cara Cara oranges offer a sweeter, less acidic taste, while Valencia oranges bring a classic, bright flavor. Avoid very sour varieties like Seville oranges unless you increase the sugar. Whichever type you choose, make sure they're fresh and fragrant for the best results.
- → Why do I need to remove the pith from the oranges for the candied slices but not for the puree?
- The white pith contains compounds that become bitter when exposed directly to heat, as happens with the candied slices. In contrast, when whole oranges are pureed into the batter, the pith's bitterness gets distributed and balanced by the sugar and other ingredients. Additionally, the pith contains pectin that helps with the cake's moisture and texture. The careful balance of removing pith from the decorative slices while keeping it in the puree gives you both beautiful presentation and deep orange flavor.
- → Can I make this cake dairy-free?
- Yes, you can easily make this cake dairy-free by substituting the plain yogurt with a plant-based alternative. Coconut yogurt works particularly well as its subtle sweetness complements the orange flavors, but any unsweetened plant-based yogurt (almond, soy, or oat) will work. Make sure to use one with a thick consistency similar to traditional yogurt for the proper texture. The rest of the ingredients are already dairy-free, making this an easy cake to adapt.
- → What type of olive oil should I use for this cake?
- For the best results, use a mild to medium-intensity extra virgin olive oil rather than a robust or peppery one that might overwhelm the orange flavor. A lighter olive oil contributes moisture and subtle fruity notes that enhance the citrus without dominating. If you prefer a completely neutral flavor profile, you can substitute light olive oil or even a neutral vegetable oil like canola, though you'll lose some of the traditional Mediterranean character that makes this cake special.
- → Why did my candied orange slices turn bitter?
- Bitterness in candied orange slices usually comes from three sources: too much pith remaining, cooking at too high a temperature, or cooking for too long. Make sure to remove as much white pith as possible from your slices before candying. Keep the syrup at a gentle simmer rather than a rolling boil, and respect the 15-minute cooking time. If you find your oranges are particularly bitter naturally, you can blanch the slices in boiling water for 1 minute, then shock in ice water before candying, which helps draw out some of the bitter compounds.
- → Can I freeze this Sicilian orange cake?
- Yes, this cake freezes beautifully! For best results, freeze the cake without the candied orange topping, which can become soggy upon thawing. Wrap the cooled cake tightly in plastic wrap, then aluminum foil, and freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator, then bring to room temperature before serving. If you'd like to freeze the complete cake with the topping, flash-freeze it unwrapped until solid, then wrap well. The texture of the candied oranges will change slightly upon thawing but will still be delicious.